What’s Really in Our 56-Point AEO + SEO Checklist

May 7, 2026

No comments

Photo of author

Brent W Peterson

People ask what’s in the audit before they trust it. Here’s the list. 56 checks across 12 categories. Every site we audit gets graded against every applicable item.

Categories 1 through 10 run on every site. Local SEO and Migration are conditional. Local checks return N/A for businesses with no physical location or service area. Migration checks return N/A unless the site moved in the last 90 days. The version with the what, the how, the why, and the tool for each of the 56 items is published as the 56-Point AEO and SEO Audit Checklist, laid out so a team can work through it on its own.

1. Crawlability and Indexing

The first thing search engines do is discover your pages. The first thing AI engines do is read your robots and your sitemap. If those signals are wrong, nothing else matters.

  • 1.1 robots.txt sanity check
  • 1.2 XML sitemap exists and is registered
  • 1.3 Stale sitemap cleanup in Search Console
  • 1.4 noindex audit
  • 1.5 IndexNow protocol setup

2. URL Structure and Redirects

Wrong redirects, mixed canonical signals, and inconsistent URL conventions leak ranking equity. This category catches the leaks.

  • 2.1 Redirect chain depth (one hop max)
  • 2.2 www vs non-www consolidation
  • 2.3 Trailing slash consistency
  • 2.4 HTTPS enforcement
  • 2.5 Canonical tag accuracy

3. On-Page SEO

The fundamentals. What every page tells the engines about itself.

  • 3.1 Title tag uniqueness and length
  • 3.2 Meta description presence and CTR quality
  • 3.3 H1 uniqueness per page
  • 3.4 Keyword placement in title, H1, and first 100 words
  • 3.5 Image alt text coverage

4. Schema and Structured Data

What machines read when they parse your page. Schema is the layer where AI engines build their understanding of your brand.

  • 4.1 Appropriate schema type per page type
  • 4.2 AggregateRating placement rules
  • 4.3 Review schema name match between page and markup
  • 4.4 BreadcrumbList on interior pages
  • 4.5 FAQ schema for question-and-answer content

5. Performance and Core Web Vitals

Google ranks on these. AI engines weight them. Buyers leave when pages drag.

  • 5.1 LCP under 2.5 seconds
  • 5.2 INP under 200 milliseconds
  • 5.3 CLS under 0.1
  • 5.4 Image optimization (format, size, lazy loading)
  • 5.5 Render-blocking resources audit

6. Social and Open Graph

Every share of your URL on Facebook, LinkedIn, Slack, X, or iMessage renders either a curated preview or a generic default. The difference is in this category.

  • 6.1 og:image exists and resolves
  • 6.2 og:image dimensions (1200 x 630)
  • 6.3 og:title, og:description, and Twitter card meta tags
  • 6.4 Social debugger verification

7. Mobile

Search happens on mobile. Google indexes mobile-first.

  • 7.1 Mobile responsive layout
  • 7.2 Touch target sizes
  • 7.3 Viewport meta tag
  • 7.4 Mobile-first indexing confirmation

8. Content Quality

The work that’s hardest to fake. Word counts, expertise signals, duplicate content patterns, and freshness.

  • 8.1 E-E-A-T signals present
  • 8.2 Thin content audit
  • 8.3 Internal duplicate content
  • 8.4 Keyword cannibalization
  • 8.5 Content freshness signals

9. Opportunity Mining

What Search Console knows that you don’t. Queries close to ranking. Pages with traffic but no conversion. Where to push next.

  • 9.1 Striking-distance queries (positions 8 to 20)
  • 9.2 Low-CTR winners
  • 9.3 Decaying pages
  • 9.4 Brand-search ranking fragmentation

10. AI Search and GEO

The newest category and the one most sites are sleeping on. ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews read your site differently than Google’s crawler. This category audits what they see. Items 10.1 and 10.2 have their own worked-out version in the robots.txt and llms.txt Punch List, with a template for each file and a named list of which AI search crawlers to allow and which training crawlers to block.

  • 10.1 llms.txt file exists
  • 10.2 AI crawler allowlist (GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot)
  • 10.3 Passage-level citability
  • 10.4 FAQ format for common questions
  • 10.5 Schema markup for AI comprehension

11. Local SEO (conditional)

Runs for businesses with a physical location or service area. Returns N/A otherwise.

  • 11.1 Google Business Profile completeness
  • 11.2 NAP consistency across citations
  • 11.3 Local schema markup
  • 11.4 Review generation and response cadence

12. Migration-Specific (conditional)

Runs for sites that moved in the last 90 days (platform change, domain change, structural rewrite). Returns N/A otherwise.

  • 12.1 Redirect mapping (old URL to new URL pairs)
  • 12.2 Sitemap resubmission post-migration
  • 12.3 Re-indexing request for top pages
  • 12.4 Pre/post traffic monitoring
  • 12.5 Backlink profile preservation check

What you do with this list

Run it on your own site. Grade each check Pass, Partial, or Fail. Categories weight by impact. Some checks require Search Console access, some require GA4, some require direct CMS access. The ones you can grade yourself, grade now. The ones you can’t, that’s where outside help shows up.

Or request the audit. We deliver it across all categories, score it, and rank the fixes by severity. The highest-impact items rarely live where people expect them.

Let us help you rank higher with human-written SEO content

Our SEO Content Services →

Why the GSC API cannot show you what is broken

Your Website Is Fine. The AI Still Cannot See You.

Leave a Comment